If you contract through a limited company, IR35 status is the single biggest variable in your annual take-home pay — often a five-figure difference on the same day rate. This calculator shows you the spread, with the full breakdown for both scenarios.
UK IR35 Calculator: Inside vs. Outside
Side-by-side comparison of contractor take-home when working through a limited company (outside) vs. via PAYE/umbrella (inside). 2025/26 HMRC rates.
Outside IR35 model assumes a single-director limited company taking the tax-optimal salary of £12,570 plus dividends, paying Corporation Tax (19–25% sliding) on profits. Inside IR35 model assumes PAYE via an umbrella deducting employer NI, apprenticeship levy, and a weekly margin.
Outside IR35 breakdown
Inside IR35 breakdown
What is IR35, in 60 seconds
IR35 is HMRC's set of rules for deciding whether a contractor is genuinely running a business or is, in substance, a disguised employee of the client. If your working relationship looks like employment — fixed hours, the client supervising day-to-day, you can't send a substitute, you have no real financial risk — the engagement is inside IR35. If you control the work, can substitute, take on financial risk, and have multiple clients, you're probably outside.
Since the April 2021 off-payroll rules, the IR35 determination for most private-sector engagements is made by the client, not you, via a Status Determination Statement (SDS). Public-sector contracts have been client-determined since 2017. If you disagree, you have 45 days to challenge.
Status is per-engagement, not per-person. You can be outside IR35 on one contract and inside on another running concurrently. The calculator above projects one engagement — run it twice if you have multiple.
How the two scenarios differ
Outside IR35 — limited company, optimal split
Your company invoices the client, you pay yourself a small "director's salary" pegged to the Personal Allowance (£12,570) so it incurs no income tax, and the remaining profit is paid out as dividends. Corporation Tax of 19–25% (with marginal relief between £50k and £250k profit) is paid by the company first; the dividend allowance shelters the first £500 in your hands, then 8.75% / 33.75% / 39.35% rates apply across the basic, higher, and additional bands.
Inside IR35 — PAYE via umbrella
The full day-rate is treated as employment income. The fee-payer (often an umbrella) deducts employer National Insurance, the apprenticeship levy (0.5%), and their own margin before you see a payslip. The remaining "gross taxable pay" then runs through standard PAYE — income tax 20/40/45 and employee NI 8/2 — leaving you with the kind of take-home a salaried employee earning the same notional figure would get. No dividends, no Corporation Tax sheltering, no business expense claims.
The numbers, at typical day rates
For a £500/day contract worked 220 days, the calculator typically shows roughly:
- Outside IR35: around £84k take-home, with £16k of business expenses sheltering and the bulk of profit drawn as dividends taxed at 8.75 / 33.75%.
- Inside IR35: around £70k take-home, after umbrella margin, employer NI on the assignment rate, and standard PAYE.
- Difference: typically £12–16k a year on a £500/day contract, depending on expense level and umbrella margin. The gap widens at higher day rates because more income tips into the 40% PAYE band when inside, while outside, dividend tax stays at 33.75%.
How to actually be outside IR35
- Right of substitution. Your contract should genuinely let you send a qualified substitute, and the client should accept this in practice — not just on paper.
- Control over how you work. The client tells you the outcome they want; you decide the method, hours, and approach. Lockstep hours and daily direction look like employment.
- Financial risk. You absorb the cost of rework, you have your own equipment, you don't get paid for holidays or sickness. "Day rate plus expenses" with no risk is a flag.
- Multiple clients matter. Genuinely running a business means not being economically dependent on one client. Two or three active engagements helps your status.
- Don't use the office Christmas party. Sounds trivial, but in tribunal cases tiny employment-like benefits (team meetings, ID badges, all-staff communications) tip the balance.
- Use HMRC CEST and get a second opinion. The official CEST tool gives a determination; an independent IR35 review service (QDOS, Markel, Bauer & Cottrell) gives you a defensible second view to challenge an SDS.
Frequently asked questions
Can I negotiate a higher rate when inside IR35?
Yes — and you should. Most contractors aim for an inside-IR35 rate that is 20–25% higher than their equivalent outside rate to compensate for the lost tax efficiency. Whether the market actually pays that uplift depends on the client and the role.
Does this calculator handle company pension contributions?
Not yet. Employer pension contributions from a limited company are highly tax-efficient when outside IR35 (deductible against Corporation Tax, no NI). Adding £10–20k/year to a SIPP via the company can shift several thousand pounds of after-tax value into your retirement pot — a follow-up calculator for this is on the roadmap.
What about Employment Allowance?
Single-director-only limited companies (the typical contractor setup) cannot claim Employment Allowance. The calculator assumes that. If you have at least one other employee on the payroll earning above the secondary threshold, your company can claim up to £10,500/year in 2025/26 — worth modelling separately.
Are umbrella margins really £25/week?
That's a mid-market default. Umbrella margins range from around £15/week for the leanest operators to £35–40/week for white-label brands. Always ask for a Key Information Document (KID) showing the full breakdown before signing on.
Does the calculator account for student loans?
No. Student loan repayments would reduce take-home in both scenarios but typically affect the inside-IR35 number more (because more income runs through PAYE). For an exact figure including student loan, run our UK Take-Home Pay Calculator on the inside-IR35 gross.
Got side income too?
Pair this with our Side-Hustle Tax Calculator if you have casual income on top of your contracting work.